I think Penguins’ victory over the Red Wings in the Stanley Cup Finals is one of the most underrated upsets in recent memory. For all the skills of Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Jordan Staal and Marc-Andre Fleury (and apparently Max Talbot as well), the Red Wings were so much deeper and more experienced than the Penguins.
Let’s compare the players by position for Detroit to those of Pittsburgh.
|Pavel Datsyuk||Sidney Crosby|
|Henrik Zetterberg||Evgeni Malkin|
|Valtteri Filppula||Jordan Staal|
|Darren Helm||Tyler Kennedy|
|Kris Draper||Max Talbot|
|Johan Franzen||Ruslan Fedotenko|
|Jiri Hudler||Chris Kunitz|
|Tomas Kopecky||Matt Cooke|
|Ville Leino||Pascal Dupuis|
|Dan Cleary||Bill Guerin|
|Marian Hossa||Miroslav Satan|
|Mikael Samuelsson||Petr Sykora|
|Tomas Holmstrom||Craig Adams|
|Kirk Maltby||Eric Godard|
|Nicklas Lidstrom||Sergei Gonchar|
|Niklas Kronwall||Kris Letang|
|Brian Rafalaski||Brook Orpik|
|Brad Stuart||Rob Scuderi|
|Jonathan Ericcson||Mark Eaton|
|Brett Lebda||Hall Gill|
|Andreas Lilja||Philippe Boucher|
|Chris Osgood||Marc-Andre Fleury|
To me, it’s evident that the Red Wings are deeper and have greater overall skill than the Penguins. I don’t believe for a second that Pittsburgh wanted it more than Detroit. Perhaps age had to do with something to do with it but Detroit surely didn’t look old in winning 3 games at home.
I’m searching for some type of comparison to fully highly the magnitude of this upset. It’s not quite Giants over Patriots in the Superbowl but it’s not far off. While the Red Wings weren’t as dominant as that Patriots team, they have been the class of the NHL for the better part of the past decade. They have won in all aspects of the game – execution, timing, skill, talent, depth, money, coaching and scouting. And unlike New England – class as well.
The Penguins chipped the puck in behind the goal continuously. They played possession as much as possible. They threw the puck at Chris Osgood at every chance. They stood toe-to-toe with one of the top 2-3 finest organizations in sports and didn’t back down.
Bottomline: The Penguins outworked a team with superior depth of talent.